SEO Comparison: Same Article on 4 Lyme Disease Websites
How the Same Lyme Disease Article Produced Wildly Different Results Across 4 Health Websites
Summary
This case study compares the real-world SEO performance of the exact same article — Dr. Myriah Hinchey's piece on natural Lyme disease treatment — published across four separate health and wellness websites, each with a different level of SEO optimization. Over one year the traffic gap between the least and most optimized version was over 50x, proving that on-page SEO execution matters far more than domain authority alone.
The winning version on TAOVitality.com accumulated 80,540 total views by January 2025, while the version on a well-established health magazine with years of aged content and high Domain Rating barely reached 219 views.
Same Lyme Article on 4 Different Websites
Article Views After 1 Year by Website
TAO — 11,811 views after 1st year.
*It grew 80+ views a day in the second year until the website was redesigned (not by me).
Views
Context
The study originated with Dr. Myriah Hinchey paying for an advertorial in Natural Nutmeg Magazine for an upcoming Lyme Disease conference. After seeing the article receive only 30 views on NaturalNutmeg.com, the same article was republished on three additional websites — each with progressively more SEO effort applied.
The four websites represent different levels of domain maturity and SEO investment:
1. NaturalNutmeg.com — An established health & wellness industry magazine with years of aged, relevant content, high Domain Rating, and backlinks from dozens of industry-relevant domains. 2. LymeDiseaseConference.com — A Lyme conference event marketing website with basic SEO applied. 3. LymeCore.com — Dr. Hinchey's natural Lyme supplements website with a homepage banner link and moderate on-page SEO. 4. TAOVitality.com — Dr. Hinchey's private practice website with maximum SEO efforts including constant data-driven rewrites based on Google Search Console, enhanced video media, and strategic interlinking.
Methodology
The same core article was published on all four domains. Each version received a different level of SEO treatment:
- Website #1 (NaturalNutmeg.com): No SEO optimization — published as-is from the magazine advertorial. - Website #2 (LymeDiseaseConference.com): Basic SEO — standard on-page optimization. - Website #3 (LymeCore.com): Moderate SEO — homepage banner link and additional on-page optimization. - Website #4 (TAOVitality.com): Maximum SEO — continuous content rewrites driven by Google Search Console data (without changing meaning), enhanced video media additions, and strategic internal linking.
Traffic was measured via analytics over a one-year observation period, with a follow-up measurement in January 2025.
Findings
- NaturalNutmeg.com (no SEO, highest domain authority): 219 views after 1 year.
- LymeDiseaseConference.com (basic SEO): 551 views after 1 year.
- LymeCore.com (moderate SEO + homepage banner): 1,290 views after 1 year.
- TAOVitality.com (maximum SEO effort): 11,811 views after 1 year — growing to 80,540 total views by January 2025.
- The highest-authority domain (NaturalNutmeg.com) performed the worst despite years of aged industry content, high Domain Rating, and a large backlink profile from relevant domains.
- TAOVitality.com outperformed NaturalNutmeg.com by over 50x — the difference was entirely attributable to on-page SEO execution, not domain authority.
- GSC-driven content iteration (rewriting based on real search data without changing meaning) was the single most impactful SEO tactic applied.
Key Takeaway
Domain authority, aged content, and backlinks are not enough. A lower-authority website with deliberate, data-driven on-page SEO — including continuous GSC-based rewrites, video media, and strategic internal linking — will dramatically outperform an established industry domain that publishes content without optimization. The 50x traffic gap between the worst and best versions of the exact same article proves that SEO execution is the multiplier, not domain history.
Explore More Research
Browse our collection of documented SEO case studies, experiments, and concepts.